2027 Open Enrollment Checklist for High Earners

Open enrollment checklist for high earners reviewing 2027 benefit elections in an employer benefits portal

Key Takeaways

  • Open enrollment decisions reach past the paycheck: Retirement and HSA elections shape the household portfolio, equity pay and deferred compensation add to employer concentration, and beneficiary forms on group life and retirement accounts can override what the estate plan intends.
  • Not every election runs on the same clock: Health plan and FSA choices generally lock at enrollment, deferred compensation elections for 2027 pay generally must be made by your employer’s deadline (no later than December 31), and 401(k) and HSA contributions can usually be adjusted during the year.
  • High earners face limits other employees do not: The Roth catch-up rule, nondiscrimination testing on dependent care and after-tax 401(k) contributions, and low supplemental withholding on bonuses and equity pay all fall hardest on highly compensated employees.

Last Updated: Updated November 2, 2026

Note: If you own the business, our year-end tax planning 2026 checklist covers the December 31 moves for founders and owners.

Every fall, we review clients’ benefits elections alongside their financial plan, usually with the portal open on one screen and the tax projection on the other. Between reviewing paystubs, planning for next year’s salary and bonus, and talking through what has changed in the family, we almost always end up changing something.

What most open enrollment checklists miss is that these elections do not stay inside the benefits portal. The 401(k) and HSA are accounts in the household portfolio, RSUs and deferred compensation add to the same employer concentration, and the group life policy and retirement accounts pass to heirs by beneficiary form rather than by will.

This open enrollment checklist is written for high earners who receive a W-2. Below, we start with a withholding check for anyone whose pay is rising in 2027 (especially important for earners that received salary increases in late-2026), then cover how benefits connect to the portfolio and estate plan, and finish with the ten elections we review most often with high-earning clients and when each one actually locks.

Before You Enroll: Check Your Withholding Against Next Year’s Pay

The W-4 is not technically a benefits election, and it can be changed at any time, but open enrollment is the one point in the year when most employees actually study their paystub. That makes it the right moment to check federal withholding against what 2027 pay will look like. A raise, a larger bonus target, or a new equity grant all increase the tax bill, and withholding does not reliably rise with them, so for high earners the gap usually surfaces as an unexpected balance due in April.

Three gaps account for most of the April surprises we see in high-earning households:

  • Bonuses are withheld at a flat 22%: Employers generally withhold federal tax on bonuses and other supplemental wages at 22% up to $1 million (37% above that), so a $150,000 bonus paid to someone in the 35% bracket is underwithheld by about $19,500.
  • Each employer withholds as if its paycheck were the only one: Unless the Step 2 box on the W-4 is checked or extra withholding is added, two working spouses are each withheld at rates that ignore the other’s income, even though their combined wages land in a higher bracket than either payroll system sees.
  • The Additional Medicare Tax is withheld per employer: Payroll withholds the extra 0.9% only on wages above $200,000 at that employer, while a married couple owes it on combined wages above $250,000, so two spouses earning $200,000 each have nothing withheld and owe $1,350 at filing.

The safe harbor protects against the penalty, not the bill. If prior-year AGI exceeded $150,000, withholding and estimated payments that cover 110% of last year’s tax generally avoid an underpayment penalty, but a household whose income jumps in 2027 can meet that test and still owe a five-figure balance next April. That is a cash-flow problem rather than a penalty problem, and it is far easier to solve with twelve months of paychecks than with one check in April.

In most cases the fix is a new W-4. We run the projected 2027 salary, bonus, and vesting schedule through the household tax projection (the IRS Tax Withholding Estimator works for simpler situations), then add a flat dollar amount per paycheck in Step 4(c) to close the gap. Federal withholding is also treated as paid evenly through the year no matter when it comes out of the paycheck, so a shortfall discovered in the fall can still be covered by extra withholding in December, which a late estimated payment cannot do. For Pennsylvania residents, the state side usually takes care of itself, since the flat 3.07% rate means state withholding on a bonus lands close to the tax actually owed.

Withholding is the paycheck-level check. The broader one is how each election fits the household balance sheet, which is the plus one we add to every review.

Ten Elections, Plus One: How Benefits Connect to the Portfolio and Estate Plan

Most open enrollment advice treats each screen as a standalone tax decision. We look at the same elections as pieces of one household balance sheet, because for a high earner the benefits package often holds a meaningful share of the family’s savings, its largest concentration risk, and much of its life insurance. There are three places we connect them before a client clicks submit.

  • The Portfolio: Benefits Accounts Are Part of the Allocation: A 401(k), an invested HSA, and a deferred compensation balance are not separate buckets with separate strategies. They are accounts within one portfolio, and how each is invested should depend on what the others hold.
  • The Estate Plan: Beneficiary Forms Override the Will: Most of the assets touched at open enrollment pass by beneficiary designation, not by will or trust. A carefully drafted estate plan can be undone by a group life form that still names a former spouse, or a 401(k) form that names minor children directly.
  • Risk: Protecting the Largest Asset on the Balance Sheet: For a 45-year-old executive, future earnings are usually worth more than everything already saved, and the benefits package is where most of that earning power is insured. Group disability and life coverage are a starting point, but both typically end when employment does and often cover only base salary.

With that framing in place, the checklist below becomes a set of decisions about one household rather than ten separate forms.

1. Reset Your 401(k) Deferral for the 2027 Limit

A deferral you set years ago, whether in dollars or percentage of salary, was likely sized to an older limit and an older salary. If you elected a flat dollar amount, it will not rise on its own, and a percentage that reached the limit in 2026 may fall short of the projected $25,500 for 2027.

Three details to check when resetting the number for 2027:

  • Divide by pay periods: At 26 pay periods, $25,500 works out to roughly $981 per paycheck, so convert that into the percentage or dollar amount your plan asks for.
  • Ask about a true-up: If you front-load and hit the limit by September, your employer match may stop with your contributions unless the plan trues up the match after year-end.
  • Check the bonus election: Many plans treat bonus deferrals as a separate election, and leaving it at zero is a common reason high earners fall short of the limit.

State Tax Note: State tax treatment of deferrals does not always follow federal rules and vary by state. For instance, Pennsylvania taxes 401(k) deferrals when earned, so the pre-tax benefit is federal only for Pennsylvania residents. Our 401(k) contribution limits guide covers the full set of rules.

2. Confirm How Your Catch-Up Will Be Coded

If you are 50 or older and make catch-up contributions, and your prior-year FICA wages from the employer sponsoring the plan exceeded the threshold ($150,000 for 2026, projected at $155,000 for 2027 based on 2026 wages), those catch-up contributions must be Roth. The requirement began in 2026, and the final regulations generally apply starting in 2027.

Three practical effects are worth checking before the first 2027 paycheck:

  • The portal may not show it: Many election screens still show a single catch-up field, and the Roth coding happens in payroll.
  • Take-home pay will be lower: Roth contributions stay in taxable wages, so an $8,500 catch-up that used to reduce taxable income now adds about $2,975 of federal tax at a 35% bracket. Payroll withholds on those wages, but it is worth confirming the household projection still balances.
  • No Roth option means no catch-up: If your plan does not offer a Roth feature, affected employees generally cannot make catch-up contributions at all.

The threshold looks at wages from that specific employer, not household income. For households weighing the Roth trade against their bracket, our guide on Tax Planning Strategies for High-Earning W-2 Employees covers the other levers available to W-2 earners.

3. Turn On After-Tax Contributions and In-Plan Roth Conversion

Once deferrals are maxed, the next layer of capacity is after-tax contributions converted to Roth (i.e. The Mega Backdoor Roth). Total 401(k) additions were capped at $72,000 in 2026, with 2027 projected at $75,000, and catch-up contributions do not count toward that total.

Three conditions have to line up for this to work:

  • The plan has to offer both features: You need after-tax contributions plus an in-plan conversion or withdrawal, ideally automatic, because earnings that build up before conversion are taxable when converted.
  • There has to be room under the limit: Your deferrals, employer match, and profit sharing all count first, so the space available is often smaller than people assume.
  • Testing can cap highly paid employees: After-tax contributions are subject to nondiscrimination testing, and plans that fail can refund contributions to highly compensated employees after year-end.

Note: Households above the Roth IRA income limits can also potentially layer in the backdoor Roth IRA.

4. Choose the Health Plan First, Then Fund the HSA

The health plan decision comes first, and the HSA’s tax benefit should not drive it. This is a personal decision that should be made based on what is best for you and your family, not just net worth.

When we discuss it with clients we always start with total expected cost: premiums, the deductible and out-of-pocket maximum, the employer’s HSA contribution, provider networks, and prescription costs. For instance, a family expecting a surgery or a new baby can come out behind in an HDHP even after the tax savings.

When the HDHP fits, the HSA is deductible going in, grows tax-free, and comes out tax-free for qualified medical expenses. The 2027 limits are $4,500 for self-only coverage and $9,000 for family coverage, plus a $1,000 catch-up at 55, and employer contributions count toward those limits.

Note: Once again state rules do not necessarily follow Federal, although Pennsylvania also excludes HSA contributions from state income tax.

Three habits make the account work as intended:

  • Treat it as a long-term account: Paying current medical bills out of pocket when cash flow allows lets the HSA stay invested.
  • Save your receipts: Qualified expenses incurred after the HSA is opened can generally be reimbursed in a later year, as long as you can document them.
  • Check eligibility month by month: HSA eligibility is generally determined monthly, and coverage under a spouse’s general-purpose health FSA, or Medicare enrollment, can end it. IRS Publication 969 covers the rules.

If both spouses have employer coverage, compare both plans side by side.

5. Elect the Dependent Care FSA, and Check the Testing

The dependent care FSA limit rose to $7,500 in 2026, or $3,750 for married couples filing separately, the first permanent increase since 1986. Note: Employers had to amend their plans to offer the higher amount, so confirm yours has before raising an election from $5,000.

For high earners, three restrictions impact making the election:

  • Nondiscrimination testing: If lower-paid employees do not use the benefit enough, highly compensated employees can have their elections cut back or the excess made taxable, which is common at companies with many highly paid staff.
  • Household and earned income limits: The $7,500 limit applies per household rather than per spouse, and both spouses generally need earned income, with exceptions for a spouse who is a full-time student or disabled.
  • The credit coordination: At high incomes the child care credit generally falls to 20% of up to $3,000 of expenses for one child or $6,000 for two or more, and every dollar excluded through the FSA reduces those eligible expenses, so the FSA usually comes out ahead.

Also keep in mind that balances generally do not carry forward, so elect only what you expect to spend.

6. Pair the HSA With a Limited-Purpose FSA

Continuing on the FSA discussion, one way we like to utilize it is in conjunction with an HDHP. This can let you invest the HSA, while still getting tax benefits for upcoming medical expenses.

Three timing rules to keep in mind about the FSA:

  • Elect limited purpose, not general: Coverage under a general-purpose health FSA generally makes you ineligible to contribute to an HSA for the months you are covered.
  • Watch the grace period when switching plans: A grace period or carryover on a 2026 general-purpose FSA can block HSA contributions in early 2027 unless the balance is zero or the plan converts it to limited purpose.
  • Know which deadline is which: The grace period, if your plan has one, extends the time to incur expenses, while the run-out period only extends the time to submit claims for expenses already incurred.

7. Make Your 2027 Deferred Compensation Election on Time

This is the election with the hardest deadline since it typically has to be made before the new year starts (and many employers close the window with their benefit changes in November).

Deferred compensation can make sense for many high earners, but there are a few important nuances to understand.

  • Most importantly, deferred amounts are unsecured claims against your employer, adding to the concentration risk of working for, and often holding stock in, the same company.
  • The distribution schedule is generally fixed at the same time, and changing it later requires a new election made at least twelve months in advance that pushes payment out at least five more years.
  • Certain performance-based bonuses tied to a period of at least twelve months follow a separate, later deadline.

State tax law also matters here, since for an executive who might retire to another state, the schedule chosen this year can decide which state taxes the money. The plan also has its own beneficiary form, separate from the 401(k), so confirm it matches the estate plan.

Most Benefits Windows Close Before the Year Does

We review open enrollment elections alongside your tax projection, while there is still time to change them.

8. Revisit the ESPP and Plan Your Equity Withholding

Many ESPPs offer a discount of up to 15% on company stock, with qualified plans limiting purchases to $25,000 of stock per year measured at its grant-date value.

The discount is valuable, but it adds to the concentration most executives already carry through RSUs and options, which means it needs to be balanced within the context of your overall investment portfolio (Note: it also creates embedded tax concentration risk; see our guide to managing a concentrated stock position).

Withholding is the other area we focus on, and RSUs carry two issues beyond the bonus withholding gap covered above:

  • Supplemental withholding runs low: RSU vests are typically withheld at the same flat 22% federal rate as bonuses up to $1 million of supplemental wages, well below a 35% or 37% marginal bracket.
  • Sell-to-cover only covers the withholding: Shares sold at vest generally fund the 22% withheld rather than the full tax, so the remaining 13 to 15 percentage points have to come from cash at filing or from the W-4 adjustment described above, ideally sized before a large Q4 vest.

9. Review Supplemental Life and Disability Coverage

This is a big topic, and it’s usually something we spend a lot of time reviewing with all new clients. Specifically, many plans let employees add or increase coverage at enrollment without medical underwriting, depending on the plan and your enrollment history. For a family that depends on one high income, that capacity is worth considering even alongside private policies.

That said, before making the election (and paying additional premiums out of pocket), ask the following questions about the group coverage:

  • Who pays the LTD premium: If your employer pays it with pre-tax dollars, any disability benefit is taxable, while paying the premium with after-tax dollars generally makes the benefit tax-free.
  • What happens when you leave: Group coverage rarely follows you to a new employer, and converting it is usually expensive. However, supplemental coverage can often be converted without new underwriting.
  • What income is covered: Group disability often caps benefits at 60% of base salary, so bonus and equity income may not be covered at all. For many high earners that means combining employer coverage with a supplemental disability policy.
  • Who is named as beneficiary: While you are on the life insurance screen, confirm the beneficiary designation still matches the estate plan.

10. New for 2027: Check for a Trump Account Employer Contribution

Some employers are adding Section 128 contributions to Trump Accounts for employees’ children this enrollment season. Under the proposed regulations, the cap is $2,500 per employee per year, indexed after 2027, and it counts toward the $5,000 annual limit per child (Note: The regulations are not yet final, so the details could change).

If your employer offers it, three things are worth knowing:

  • Open the account first: Your child needs a Trump Account before the employer can fund it.
  • It is income tax free, not payroll tax free: Qualifying contributions are excluded from federal income tax but generally remain wages for FICA.
  • The program has to be offered broadly: Employer programs are subject to nondiscrimination rules, and contributions do not create basis, so the full amount eventually comes out of the account as ordinary income.

2027 Benefit Limits at a Glance

Retirement plan limits for 2027 are projections until the IRS publishes its annual adjustments, which is generally expected in November. The rest of the figures below are final.

Benefit2026 Limit2027 LimitStatus
401(k) employee deferral$24,500$25,500Projected
Catch-up, age 50+$8,000$8,500Projected
Catch-up, ages 60 through 63$11,250$11,750Projected
Total 401(k) additions (415(c))$72,000$75,000Projected
Roth catch-up wage threshold$150,000$155,000Projected
HSA, self-only / family$4,400 / $8,750$4,500 / $9,000Final
HSA catch-up, age 55+$1,000$1,000Fixed by statute
Dependent care FSA$7,500$7,500Fixed by statute

Coordinating the Elections With the Plan

Each of these elections sits on a separate screen, often with a separate vendor, but they all draw on the same paycheck, the same tax return, and the same balance sheet.

That is why we treat open enrollment as more than choosing health coverage. It is an annual checkpoint for the tax projection, the portfolio’s concentration, the family’s insurance, and the beneficiary forms that carry out the estate plan, and when two spouses enroll at two companies, that coordination is the part most worth reviewing with an advisor before the window closes.

Talk with our team to learn more about how we work with high-earning families.


Frequently Asked Questions

What should high earners change at open enrollment for 2027?

Start with the 401(k) deferral, since the 2027 limit is projected at $25,500. Confirm how any catch-up will be coded, compare health plans on total cost before funding an HSA, check whether your dependent care FSA allows $7,500, and make any deferred compensation election before your employer’s deadline.

Do I have to make Roth catch-up contributions in 2027?

Catch-up contributions are optional. If you make them and your 2026 FICA wages from the employer sponsoring the plan exceed the indexed threshold, projected at $155,000, they must be designated Roth and are not deductible. If your plan has no Roth option, affected employees generally cannot make catch-up contributions.

Is the dependent care FSA limit $7,500 in 2027?

Yes. The One Big Beautiful Bill Act raised the dependent care FSA limit to $7,500 starting in 2026, or $3,750 for married couples filing separately, and it is not indexed. Employers must amend their plans to offer it, and highly compensated employees can still be limited by nondiscrimination testing.

Can I change my deferred compensation election after December 31?

Generally, no. Under Section 409A, an election to defer 2027 compensation must be made before 2027 begins, and many employers set an earlier deadline. Changing the payout timing later requires an election made twelve months in advance that delays payment at least five years. Some performance-based bonuses have a later deadline.

Why do high earners owe taxes in April even with withholding?

Most often because bonuses and RSU vests are withheld at a flat 22% federal rate while the income is taxed at 35% or 37%, and because each spouse’s employer withholds as if its paycheck were the household’s only income. A new W-4 with extra withholding per paycheck usually closes the gap.

Your Benefits Elections Should Work as One Plan

We coordinate both spouses’ benefits with the household’s portfolio, estate, and tax plan for 2027.

Figures reflect federal and Pennsylvania rules as of November 2, 2026. 2027 retirement plan limits are Milliman and Marsh projections pending IRS cost-of-living adjustments, expected in November 2026. Sources: IRS Revenue Procedure 2026-24 (HSA limits), Public Law 119-21 (OBBBA), final regulations on Roth catch-up contributions, Treasury regulations under Sections 409A and 423, proposed regulations under Section 128, IRS Form W-4, IRS Publications 15, 15-B, 503, 505, and 969, and the Pennsylvania Department of Revenue Personal Income Tax Guide. Plan features vary by employer, and individual circumstances differ; this is general information, not individualized tax or legal advice.


Please read important disclosures here.

Wealth Management Insights

Request an Introduction

Let’s discuss how a personalized strategy can help you navigate your wealth and achieve your goals.

Submit the form below and we’ll reach out to schedule a meeting. During this meeting we’ll review your situation, provide more information about our process, and see if our services are a fit for you.

What service are you reaching out about?

Stay in Touch

Enter your email address below to join our newsletter.